Forge and Fire Gaming: The Complete Buyer’s Guide (Reviews, Coupons, & More)

If you’ve been hunting for Pokémon booster boxes at actual retail price, not the scalped-up nonsense you find on secondary markets, there’s a good chance someone in your community has already mentioned Forge and Fire Gaming. And there’s an equally good chance you showed up here wanting to know if it’s actually worth your time and money.

Fair question. This hstech guide covers everything: what the store sells, how it handles shipping and pre-orders, what real customers are saying, how to find a Forge and Fire Gaming coupon, and the handful of policy quirks you’ll want to know before you check out.

What Is Forge and Fire Gaming?

Forge and Fire Gaming is a collectable trading card game (TCG) retailer based in St. Louis, Missouri. The physical store is located at 6330 Telegraph Rd, Saint Louis, MO 63129, and can be reached by phone at 314-293-9833.

Beyond the brick-and-mortar location, Forge and Fire Gaming operates a full e-commerce site at forgeandfiregaming.com and sells across multiple platforms, including eBay, Walmart Marketplace, and TCGPlayer.

The store offers a variety of games and accessories for all types of gamers, including booster packs, special editions, and premium collections for games like Pokémon, Magic: The Gathering, and Flesh & Blood.

What sets them apart from a sea of online card retailers is their consistent MSRP pre-order model. While most stores either price-gouge on hot sets or cancel orders when a product spikes in secondary market value, Forge and Fire has built a reputation, imperfect but genuine, for honouring pre-orders at original retail pricing.

Forge and Fire Gaming Location and Store Hours

The St. Louis retail location isn’t just a warehouse; it’s a working game store with in-person play events.

Store hours are Tuesday through Thursday from 3:00 PM to 9:00 PM, Friday from 3:00 PM to 9:00 PM, and Saturday from 12:00 PM to 4:00 PM. The store is closed on Sunday and Monday.

If you’re a local player or live within driving distance of St. Louis, in-person visits during event nights give you the added benefit of community play, which the store actively supports. Forge and Fire Gaming is also listed as an official Flesh & Blood retailer on the FAB TCG locator, worth noting if you’re into that game.

The Complete Guide to Book Reviews: Mastering the Art of Literary Critique with 5 Examples

What Does Forge and Fire Gaming Sell?

The product catalogue runs deep. You’ll find:

Trading Card Games is the core of what they do. Magic: The Gathering, Pokémon, Flesh & Blood, Lorcana, One Piece, and Yu-Gi-Oh products, including booster boxes, elite trainer boxes, pre-release kits, draft bundles, and single cards.

Pre-Orders at MSRP. This is their signature offering. When a new set drops, Forge and Fire often lists pre-orders at the manufacturer’s suggested retail price with strict household limits to prevent bulk buying and reselling.

Accessories and Supplies, Sleeves, deck boxes, playmats, and other gaming accessories round out the inventory.

Multi-Platform Availability, On eBay alone, Forge and Fire Gaming has sold over 22,000 items with 100% positive feedback, giving you a sense of their volume and reach beyond their website.

Forge and Fire Gaming Shipping: What to Expect

The warehouse is located in Maryland Heights, Missouri, and transit times vary based on destination. Orders placed on Friday and over the weekend will be processed the following Monday. Forge and Fire Gaming does not ship to PO Boxes.

For flat-rate shipping, orders shipping to the 48 contiguous United States that fit in a single shipping box and weigh under 50 lbs qualify. If your order requires multiple shipping boxes or exceeds 50 lbs, you’ll need to contact them for a custom shipping quote. Alaska and Hawaii require separate arrangements.

One thing that trips up a lot of first-time buyers: the “awaiting fulfilment” status. This is completely normal for pre-orders and simply means your order is in the queue, waiting for the product to arrive from the distributor before it ships out. It does not mean anything went wrong.

For pre-orders, any items combined with pre-ordered products will not ship until the last item in the order is ready to ship, unless those items qualify for free shipping or shipping is paid separately. If you want in-stock items sooner, place them as a separate order.

Shipping confirmation is emailed at the end of each business day. Tracking numbers become available within 24 hours of shipment, and account holders can view tracking from their customer account page.

Forge and Fire Gaming Reviews: The Honest Picture

Let’s not sugarcoat this: Forge and Fire Gaming has a mixed but overall positive reputation, and the variance is pretty well explained by the nature of what they sell.

What Customers Praise

Forge and Fire Gaming stands out in the realm of online collectable trading card stores, with customers frequently praising its visually appealing product presentation, which is meticulously packaged to prevent damage during shipping.

On Google, Forge and Fire Gaming holds a 4.8-star rating from 200 reviewers, a genuinely strong score for a TCG retailer that deals in high-demand, emotionally charged products like Pokémon and MTG. One Walmart Marketplace buyer summed it up well: “My order was packaged securely, shipped out quickly, and arrived in perfect condition. The cards were exactly as described, clean, crisp, and clearly handled with care.”

Their MSRP pre-order model has earned particular loyalty. When Prismatic Evolutions pre-orders were generating anxiety in the community, Forge and Fire Gaming clarified publicly that they never cancel pre-orders, regardless of price, and that all pre-orders are fulfilled from guaranteed stock. That kind of transparency matters in a hobby where pre-order cancellations are frustratingly common.

Where Things Get Complicated

The BBB complaint history and some platform reviews reveal patterns worth knowing. The no-refund policy on new releases and trading cards catches some buyers off guard. Forge and Fire Gaming does not offer refunds or returns for new-release or pre-order products. Due to price fluctuations, they also do not accept returns for sports cards or collectable card games, including Magic, Pokémon, Lorcana, One Piece, and Flesh & Blood.

This policy is standard in the industry: TCG retailers can’t accept opened product returns, so you need to read product listings carefully before purchasing. A few BBB complaints stem from customers not realizing what specific product they’d ordered.

The bottom line: Forge and Fire Gaming is a legitimate, well-run retailer. Read listings carefully, understand the return policy before you buy, and you’re unlikely to have problems.

Forge and Fire Gaming on X (Twitter)

Their official X account is @ForgeStoreSTL, and it’s genuinely useful to follow if you’re a frequent buyer.

This is where they announce new pre-order drops, communicate shipping updates for large release batches, and address community questions. They’ve shipped nearly 3,000 Journey Together Pre-Orders at MSRP, and updates like that get communicated through X first, often before email notifications go out.

If a set you pre-ordered is shipping and you’re wondering where it is, checking @ForgeStoreSTL is usually faster than waiting for a customer service reply.

How to Find Gaming Coupons

Forge and Fire Gaming does not run frequent blanket discounts; their whole model is built around selling at MSRP rather than inflating prices and then offering fake “sales.” But coupons do exist, and here’s how to find them legitimately.

Coupon aggregator sites: Sites like SimplyCodes, Knoji, and CouponBirds track community-verified Forge and Fire Gaming coupon codes. Some codes that have worked for community members include SEALEDMTGDEALS, PDC20, and FiveTwoLegends, though availability changes constantly, so verify before relying on any specific code.

Forge and Fire Gaming coupon on Reddit: Subreddits like r/mtgfinance, r/pkmntcg, and broader deal communities occasionally surface active codes. Search “Forge and Fire Gaming coupon” filtered to recent posts for the best results. Community members who receive discount codes through newsletters or promotions often share them.

Newsletter sign-up: Subscribing to the Forge and Fire Gaming email list is the most reliable way to receive first-party discount offers. Occasional newsletter-exclusive codes tend to be the most reliably valid.

Price match window: Items with a future release date are eligible for a price match if the price drops on their website before the first available ship date. For Magic, that date is two weeks prior to general release; for Pokémon, it’s one week prior. Price adjustments are given in store credit and must be requested via email before the stated deadlines.

The Ultimate Gaming Desk Guide: Find Your Perfect Setup in 2026

Tips for Getting the Best Experience Gaming

A few practical notes that will save you frustration:

Place pre-orders and in-stock items separately. Bundled orders wait for the slowest item. If you want accessories now and a booster box in three months, two orders are better than one combined order.

Create an account. Account holders can track orders directly from the customer portal. Guest checkout makes tracking more cumbersome.

Understand the return window. Forge and Fire Gaming accepts returns on many unopened products within three weeks of delivery, subject to a 10% restocking fee. That fee is waived if you elect store credit instead of a refund. All returns require an RMA approval via email before sending anything back.

Contact during business hours. Their typical response time is within 24 hours, Monday through Friday. They are closed on weekends but will respond the following business day.

Conclusion

Forge and Fire Gaming occupies a genuinely useful niche in the TCG retail space: a store that takes pre-orders seriously, prices fairly, and handles high-volume releases with more transparency than most. The 4.8-star Google rating and 22,000+ eBay sales with 100% positive feedback speak to a business that’s doing the fundamentals right.

Is it perfect? No. Their no-return policy on sealed TCG products is strict, and if you misread a product listing, you’re unlikely to get a refund. But that’s the reality of the collectable card game market, not a Forge and Fire-specific problem.

If you’re a Pokémon or Magic player looking for pre-orders at retail price without the scalper markup, Forge and Fire Gaming is one of the better options available online. Follow @ForgeStoreSTL, sign up for the newsletter for occasional coupon access, and read product descriptions before you click purchase.

How to Connect Bluetooth Headphones to PS5: The Definitive Guide

Frequently Asked Questions